Saturday, February 29th, 2020

Does Italy Really Want Search Engines? Recent Legal Rulings Suggest Not


and have felt the sting of the Italian courts recently and the numerous problems the engines seem to be having in the country almost suggests search engines are not welcome. Or maybe the search engines will just decide the effort is not worth the return and filter Italy like Google did to the search results in China.

Google was found liable for defamation of a person from their autocomplete – which is a reflection of what people are searching for, but as the case stated, Google had already filtered the autocomplete for copyright terms – so the court determined they could filter these too.

Meanwhile, Yahoo was found guilty of distributing a movie without authorization by linking to the site that was doing the distribution. “As for the reasoning behind the decision, it seems to focus on a stretch of an interpretation of the EU’s E-Commerce Directive, which indicates that a “caching provider” has to block links to content once notified that it’s infringing. While the coverage is a bit unclear, it sounds like this is more difficult than a US-style DMCA notice-and-takedown regime, in that it appears that upon notice that some content is infringing, Yahoo isn’t supposed to just take down that particular link, but all links that can reach that content,” TechDirt explained.

Previously, three Google executives were found guilty of privacy violations for not taking down a video from YouTube that made derogatory statements about an autistic child.

The Italian courts seem to think that every engine is responsible for vetting each entry as they are indexed. This is not a mechanical tweak – the type of control the Italian government requires engines to observe would mean a lot of man hours and realistically would make the process untenable.

It seems to be getting hard to run a search engine – but hey it is a tens of billions of dollars industry, I am sure something will be worked out.

Related posts:

  1. Despite Legal Woes, Google Teams with Italy for Book Digitization
  2. 77% of Americans Oppose Government Regulation of Search Engines [Survey]
  3. Universal Search Features Added to Google Suggest
  4. Google Adds New Social ‘Recent Update’ Counts To Search Results
  5. EU Request To Retain User Data From Search Engines Sparks Widespread Anger

Speak Your Mind

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!